Showing posts with label Talaat Harb. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Talaat Harb. Show all posts

Wednesday, 28 June 2017

Does history repeat itself?




I continue writing about Talaat Harb and challenging colonization… the role of Bank Misr in industrialization in the time span from 1920 to 1941 based on the highly important reference rich in its information and in-depth analyses “Challenging colonization: Bank Misr and Egyptian industrialization 1920 – 1941" written by Eric Davis, translated by Hisham Soliman Abdel-Ghaffar, revised and introduced by Mr. Dr. Ibrahim Fawzi; the one who attracted my attention to the importance of rereading the reference especially in this time in our country’s history wishing that those elite bunch possessing power in Egypt; whether the wealthy, businessmen, officials in charge or others, may make use of the lessons learnt from that era in our history.

Here, I would like to appeal to the officials in charge of Bank Misr right now and ask them to publish this book on a wide scale in Maktabet al-Osra’ publications series or other one so that every Egyptian, who wants to learn and look up to great pioneers like Talaat Harb and those who helped him, can read it… in doing such thing, Bank Misr would be returning part of the favor of that man who took the responsibility of establishing this bank.

The book author says that the support offered from students’ groups and agricultural bourgeoisie to Bank Misr resulted in that the merchants all over Egypt started forming commercial chambers in the wake of 1919 revolution… despite no evidence was given that these institutions were immersed in the promotion for buying Bank Misr’s shares, these commercial chambers were fierce in their call for boycott… they issued several statements calling for withdrawing deposits from the foreign banks and directing them to Bank Misr… they also asked for replacing Al-Ahli or the National Bank with Bank Misr since the former was controlled by the English as the very important state bank…

Also, comparisons between Al-Ahli or the National Bank enjoying the high status and Bank Misr that was just established contributed to reinforcing the position of the latter to people in general… they also helped undoubtedly in encouraging the Egyptians hesitating; those who were known to prefer investing in real estate than bank deposits in saving their money… such comparisons encouraged them to buy shares and have bank accounts in Bank Misr… Abdel-Maged al-Ramalli; secretary of Cairo commercial chamber, confirmed that if every Egyptian bought a single share of Bank Misr capital, the whole yield would be enough to fund the industrial projects Bank Misr was hoping to do.

If we added to the commercial chambers what the “agricultural bourgeoisie” did, that bourgeoisie that became more aware of its interests and so it established strong pressure group in 1920; that was the public Egyptian agricultural syndicate, to practice pressure over the government to follow policies where there interests are taken into consideration… adding to this also the orientation to establish and strengthen the cooperative movement… we would realize that the process of establishing a national bank has turned into what we may call an epic of a conscious national act where the participants in it became aware of their interests and of the conflict with the foreign capitalism.

However, things did not go well all the time as the conflict between “national” and “foreign” led the foreign capital to adopt tricks and tactics supporting it in such conflict… and so, many foreign companies tended to re-register themselves as Egyptian companies to make use of the laws and policies applied by the patriotic governments at that era…

Those companies meant to attract a number of the high class members… some other companies meant to depend on those who were granted their Egyptian nationality recently especially those of the Greek, Levant, Armenian and Jewish origins… then those foreign companies, which had re-registered as Egyptian companies, sought the help of political activists at that time… especially ex-ministers and deputy ministers; those experts in the governmental affairs and complications of laws related to the work of the Egyptian joint-stock companies.

Some of those sought for help were owners of vast areas of lands despite they did not inherit any of those lands… actually, their ownership of all those lands came from practicing politics and assuming public job positions during which they usually received bribes as “supplements for their income”.

Here, the author stops at a remarkable phenomenon and which is almost recurring since the beginning of the last century to date; that is the class resulting from the Egyptian bourgeoisie – meaning those who did not decent from families enjoying wealth or power and their grandfathers were not villages’ mayors… but actually most of their fathers were humble farmers and government employees – this class or sector was the most subordinate to the foreign capital.

In such regard, author Eric Davis wrote a very serious paragraph saying: “members of the Egyptian bourgeoisie who collaborated with the foreign capital during the thirties of the twentieth century should be looked at by using terms of the new occupation… as they represented a front hiding behind the principle controller in the companies under scrutiny… on the surface, it looked as if the Egyptians became more powerful in controlling their economy than it was the case in reality… also, a number of the members of those class were the ones who turned the tables against the financially-distressed companies of Bank Misr in 1939”!

My stating exclaiming question now: does history repeat itself?... do we witness the same phenomenon again in Egypt with the political activists since 2000 to date… those who turned the tables against the national principles when they accepted to receive foreign funds and commit to the agendas of those funding them overseas?

Translated into English by: Dalia Elnaggar



This article was published in Almasry alyoum newspaper on June 28, 2017.

To see the original article, go to:


#almasry_alyoum #ahmed_elgammal #Egypt #Talaat_Harb #economy #Bank_Misr

Wednesday, 14 June 2017

National economy in the middle of conflict




It is only a coincidence that the advertisement saying “Talaat Harb is coming back” is broadcasted in the same time of writing those lines about the same man… that man who became like many other examples in the history of our country… those whose life circumstances and details turned them from mere individuals into legends occupying the collective memory throughout consecutive historical eras.

Two weeks ago, I wrote an article that contained an introduction including details about the book “Challenging colonization: Bank Misr and Egyptian industrialization 1920 – 1941” authored by Eric Davis, translated by Hesham Soliman Abdel-Ghaffar, revised and introduced by the honorable scientist Dr. Ibrahim Fawzi; professor in Cairo University, ex-minister of industry and one of the most distinguished Egyptian minds concerned in the good scientific establishment of the coming generations.

First, I apologize to the reader for the insufficient space of the article that may be not enough to present an analytical review for what came in the book… this book is a doctorate thesis presented at Chicago University… and in my opinion, this study – just like other serious studies in the Egyptian socio-economic history – is a scientific reference that includes a distinguished analysis for the Egyptian socio-economic development and its connection to the political aspects in the first half of the twentieth century.

Here, I would like to hint quickly at the role of the department of history at the faculty of arts in Ain Shams University and the scientific seminar used to be headed by our great mentor; the late Dr. Ahmed Ezzat Abdel-Karim along with our distinguished late professor Dr. Ahmed Abdel-Rahim Mustafa in encouraging a group of researchers in the master’s and doctorate stages to tackle the socio-economic history and break the monopoly of research over political history which was regarded as the backbone of the historical studies… it also makes one feel proud when we find citations in Eric Davis’ sources and references to researches of professor Dr. Assem ad-Dessouqi; the Egyptian historian who had his PhD thesis over prominent owners of agricultural land.

Now we are about to ask a recurring question: does history repeat itself?... do its events repeat again so that one can easily say that “Talaat Harb is coming back” or that a certain era of time is recurring?... the answer to this is very simple… the past does not come back… living nations do not reproduce what have already been done in their historical eras… but what really happens or should happen is that those eras must be scientifically detected and analyzed… we should also make morals of the lessons learnt from those eras… we must make use of the accumulation of positive things that took place in those eras and not repeat the same mistakes and negative things that happened at those times too.

The most important thing one can pick from a study like this one we are talking about is what I can call the manifestations of the political-socio-economic phenomenon and what connects to it of political aspects and struggles among then-existing powers… those powers – at the time period researched by the study from 1920 to 1941 – are social classes like prominent owners of agricultural land, big merchants and groups of what is called national bourgeoisie; high, middle and low… and also like political parties; atop of them at that time was al-Wafd party, al-Omma party… then al-Ahrar ad-Dostorieen party, national or al-Watani party, ash-Sha’ab party… and standing against all those was the British occupation.

The researcher detected a backbone that connected all those developments; that is the controversial relationship between Egyptian national capital and foreign capital… and how the reality imposed by the latter; meaning foreign capital represented in banks, companies and socio-economic influence and consequently political, was the thing that contributed to creating the hope of an Egyptian national capital that started to grow to go into a clear conflict against the foreign hegemony.

The main foundation for this was what was happening in the field of agricultural land and agricultural reclamation… here, the researcher’s ability in the field of socio-economic history becomes apparent in detecting the backgrounds and introductions that reached a critical limit… the thing that prompted national powers and figures represented in some big owners of agricultural lands, some of certain families and districts like families of ash-Shirie’i, Abdel-Razeq, Khalifa Marzouq, Ahmed Ismail, at-Taweel, al-Wakeel, al-Khatieb, al-Gazzar, ash-Sha’rawi, Lamloum, Dos and al-Basel to contribute to this national capital… and so one finds in the list of those who contributed to the establishment of Bank Misr names like Swares, Rolo, Sarofeem, Mina Ebied, Salib Bey Mankariyos!

Eric Davis shortens the signs of the start when the conflict set off in lines saying: “Egypt’s incorporation in the international market during the eighteenth century was the start of important transformations in the Egyptian social structure… also the foreign capital working in Egypt increased heavily during the nineteenth century along with the change in the Egyptian economy towards trading due to the expansion in agriculture of long-staple cotton… also the economic confusion resulted from Muhammed Ali’ policies in the economic field… adding to this the need to develop the infra-structure of Egypt… all this resulted in a huge public debts…”

“This financial crisis resulted in a change in the economic and political balance of powers for the benefit of a new class formed from dignitaries of the countryside on the expense of the ruling class of Turks and Circassians… cotton agriculture represented the common ground as to the interests… the thing that paved the way for the awareness development of those dignitaries that they belong to this class… also, the common challenges that faced them like heavy taxes, their migration to urban centres, their growing participation in the national policies and the incorporation of increasing numbers of Egyptians in the government bureaucratic administration and armed forces… all these factors augmented that feeling”… we shall continue later.

Translated into English by: Dalia Elnaggar



This article was published in Almasry alyoum newspaper on June 14, 2017.

To see the original article, go to:


#almasry_alyoum #ahmed_elgammal #Talaat_Harb

Wednesday, 31 May 2017

Necessary hint




I postpone writing about Talaat Harb for a next time… as I have ended my last week’s article with a promise to write about him in the context of the role of the Egyptian capitalism in building the country… I postpone writing for two reasons… one is I have not finished yet revising the material I will use as a reference… second, it is necessary to give a detailed citation for the fundamental reference I will establish my information on… such citation opens the door for a highly important talk in my opinion despite it may seem repetitive… such talk deserves to be seriously processed… it is about the role of the scientific and intellectual elite bunch which is inseparable of the role of capital and work force together and in the same time.

This reference I would like to hint at is a doctorate thesis from Chicago University written by Eric Davis… although it was written and debated since relatively long time, its subject titled “Challenging colonization: Bank Misr and Egyptian industrialization 1920 – 1941” is still needed in the cultural, social, economic and political life in Egypt, especially during this time we live in now.

At the beginning of the research, there is an acknowledgement to tens of names who contributed to helping the researcher in his thesis including some I see it is my duty to mention them once again now since the foreign researcher was noble and honest enough to mention them name by name… first, he mentioned Mr. Galal Ezzat; husband of Talaat Harb’s granddaughter, the one who gave the researcher the chance to look at the documents of Talaat Pasha … then came Mr. Muhammed Fouad Salem who let the researcher view the documents of his father; Muhammed Fouad Salem Hegazi who was a loyal friend to Talaat Harb… then Mr. Ragheb Iskandar who offered the researcher the opportunity to see the papers of his father; Iskandar Messiha; one of the members who established the bank.

Then came names like Mr. Nabil Rafaat from the ministry of Egyptian treasury… and gentlemen employees of the Egyptian National Library and Archives that if it wasn’t for their efforts, the researcher would not have been able to study the archives’ documents… then Mr. Muhammed Amin Ahmed; administrative secretary of Talaat Harb whom the researcher said about: “… in addition to the long hours he spent with me in long conversations, he provided me with extra papers about Bank Misr… also the photos appearing in the book… his interest in this study reflected his absolute loyalty to Talaat Harb and the project of Bank Misr”.

As to Mr. Mahmoud Soliman Ghannam, he gave the researcher a copy of the unpublished records of the closed-door session of the Egyptian parliament held in 1941 to discuss the financial difficulties facing Bank Misr and its companies… after this the researcher thanked some figures like Dr. Ali el-Geritli, Mr. Fathi Radwan, Dr. Abdel-Hamid esh-Sherif, Dr. Assem ad-Dessouki, Sawsan al-Misseri, Talal Asad… and others.

I mentioned the names of those Egyptian figures whom the researcher praised… not to fill the space… and not because I know some of them closely… but to shed some light over the shining Egyptian spirit always ready to give, achieve and contribute to serious work… such spirit that does not hesitate to glow once it has the motive… the spirit that finds unlimited joy in volunteering work as long as it serves Egypt and the truth.

Now I move to the other side where the publisher and scrutinizer who wrote the introduction for the book are… as to the publisher, he is Mr. Adel al-Moa’lem whom I think was much marginalized because of the heavy shadows that hid him and clouded his role as a serious publisher… these were the shadows of his elder brother that it happened to have all the lights and roles for a reason or another… but I am not going to discuss this despite I have a lot to say in such regard.

It was Adel al-Moa’lem who paid the attention of Mr. Dr. Ibrahim Fawzi to the book… Dr. Ibrahim hinted at his story with the publisher in his introduction that occupied seven pages… in it, he wrote a long piece about Mr. Muhammed al-Moa’lem and Adel al-Moa’lem and their roles in the industry of publishing and enlightenment.

In this introduction, Mr. Ibrahim Fawzi mentioned his professor in the university college in London; that is Professor “Bishop”, who founded a high-value national, ethical and human rule in the mind of his student… he told him that true university professor has to be like a light house sending out its shining light in every direction around penetrating the gloomy sea darkness… and that those pulses of light have to keep guiding the small boats all the time like they do with the big ones despite no one knows who will come ashore on its light and who will set off in the vast sea.

And so gentlemen, Dr. Ibrahim Fawzi did not hesitate for a moment to be this light house… to simplify the difficult complicated sciences in order to enable the scientific thinking to be in reach of the vast majority of the society… here I remember I wrote months ago about the book of Quantum mechanics that Dr. Fawzi simplified.

Not a single time I met this respected scientist unless I find him burdened with the reality of our country, deeply exhausted in thinking of its future… and so I owe him a lot which I wish I can show some gratitude to him in the coming article about “Talaat Harb and challenging colonization”… hoping that wealth owners can benefit from the experiment of the pioneer of industry and national economy.

Translated into English by: Dalia Elnaggar



This article was published in Almasry alyoum newspaper on May 31, 2017.

To see the original article, go to:


#almasry_alyoum #ahmed_elgammal #Talaat_Harb #Bank_Misr #Egypt #industry #industrialization